Plenty to devour

The Bay is finally being recognised as a foodie destination for the discerning diner. Stacey Jones discovers how we got here by talking to the best in Tauranga's hospitality industry, and lists six of the most respected eateries in the region.

“I drive to Auckland for a nice meal.”

That was one of the first comments I heard when I arrived in the Bay of Plenty 15 years ago. Back then, finding a great restaurant here was like searching for a white truffle in a field of mushrooms.

Fast forward to 2024, and the Bay of Plenty has blossomed into a vibrant culinary destination. Cuisine Magazine’s Good Food Awards recognised 12 local eateries this year, with two receiving coveted hats. Further proof is the Flavours of Plenty food festival, which won double honours at last year’s New Zealand Event Awards for its collaborative approach and unique food experiences.

From Whakatāne to Waihi Beach, Te Moananui-a-Toi has transformed into a coastline brimming with gastronomic gems in the most unexpected places. Take Cigol, for example – a Korean fusion spot with unforgettable flavours on a backstreet in Whakatāne. Or discover the culinary genius of Israeli cuisine at Malka, hidden away in the Historic Village in Tauranga.

So, what has changed? Over the past 15 years, the population has swelled by a third, further fueled by the great COVID exodus. This wave brought people from all over the globe in search of the metropolitan dining experiences they were accustomed to in the 'big smoke', in turn leading to a surge of new restaurant experiences.

The heroes in this story are the fearless restaurateurs who’ve poured their hearts and souls into redefining the Bay’s dining scene. Noel Cimadom of the Clarence Group, winner of this year’s Outstanding Achievement Award at the Bay of Plenty Hospitality Awards, notes, “We have experienced a great shift in the Bay in the last six years. This shift has seen operators take bold steps away from the usual fare of burgers and fish 'n' chips to offer innovative and exciting dining experiences.”

Alongside traditional restaurants, a vibrant pop-up culture has emerged. Spots like Mexa, Amador, Rika Rika, Kitchen Takeover, and Rose’s Dining Table have added flair to Tauranga's food scene. Private chefs like Madeleine Hughes, trained at Le Cordon Bleu and experienced on superyachts, offer in-home dining experiences, bringing even more sophistication to local tables.

Yet, it’s not all smooth sailing. Nick Potts of Solera, one of the region’s most innovative restaurants, acknowledges the challenges. “The last 18 months have been really tough, and while some restaurants serving lower-quality food at the same price or more are busy, we have struggled,” he says. Noel Cimadom believes the future lies with the diners: “The more people start going out and supporting our local venues, the better the quality and consistency we will achieve.”

ALPINO

Alpino, founded by Italian-born restaurateur Noel Cimadom and his wife Kim, offers authentic Italian soul food reminiscent of a warm embrace from Nonna. Their goal was to recreate the simple Italian cuisine with great local products they missed from Europe, and this authenticity shines through in every plate. Noel explains, “Alpino is all about the people, the vibe, the sun, and a good plate of pasta.“ Head chef Scott Rowan brings experience from Melbourne’s Italian restaurants, focusing on simple dishes that highlight the best locally sourced ingredients without unnecessary embellishments. Noel explains, “Scott has a real talent to pull back recipes to only leave on the plate what is really needed. No fancy stuff, garnish, or flowers. Just a slug of the best olive oil giving rise to a menu that is humble, fresh, and seasonal.“

Insider foodie tip: Book ahead as it’s always rammed and ask for a table outside to enjoy the afternoon sun while sipping prosecco.

PICNICKA

Picnicka, is a bar and grill concept that embodies the essence of a New York steakhouse, offering a menu centred around local produce and seasonal inspirations. The fit out is arguably the Bay’s most glamourous, offering a big-city vibe within Tauranga’s CBD. Executive chef Ryan Allen crafts dishes that highlight the flavours imparted by wood-fire cooking, with most items either grilled over charcoal or served raw to retain the integrity of the food. “The menu is designed for sharing, encouraging a communal dining experience reminiscent of a family gathering,” explains owner Noel Cimadon (can you spot the pattern?). Signature dishes include fish with tamarind, chilli, cucumber, and coriander, and barbecued chicken with lime, guindillas, and yoghurt.

Insider foodie tip: On a budget? Try the $29 worker’s lunch, a two-course steal available Monday-Friday.

SOLERA

Established nearly four years ago, Solera offers a unique dining experience inspired by open-fire cooking, delivered by head chef David Bryson. Owner Nick Potts explains, “Coming from Melbourne to the Mount four years ago, my wife and I felt the area was missing a restaurant offering world-class food in a relaxed, casual setting.“ He adds, “The open fireplace, focusing on hearth-style cooking, is the main driving force behind what we do. But we are also keeping in touch with what is happening around the globe and playing around with new flavour combinations.“ The menu is complemented by an outstanding wine list curated by Nick himself, celebrating Aotearoa’s wine makers, many available by the glass so you can meander through.

Insider foodie tip: Book a spot at the bar to watch the chefs in action; it won't disappoint.

CLARENCE BISTRO

Clarence is a testament to tenacity and perseverance. Situated in the heart of Tauranga, this stunning heritage building – originally an old post office – has undergone numerous foodie transformations over the past seven years and now appears to have found its stride. Clarence’s latest iteration offers an approachable menu that includes shared plates, pizzas, and handmade pasta, all paired with exceptional wines and hospitality. Executive chef Ryan Allen, with experience in Dubai and Auckland, draws inspiration from the Mediterranean, crafting dishes influenced by the cuisines of Portugal, Spain, France, Italy, and the Middle East. Signature offerings include cauliflower with ajo blanco and brown butter vinaigrette, raw beef with capsicum, freekeh, and almonds, and cappelletti pasta with leek, macadamia, and pecorino. Arguably the most beautiful restaurant in the Bay, both inside and out, Clarence features a delightful summer terrace perfect for soaking up the sunshine.

Insider foodie tip: Opt for “Our Choice”, a more casual approach to a tasting menu offering. excellent value at just $85pp.

POCO TAPAS & WINE

Considering Rotorua is New Zealand’s second-largest tourism destination, restaurants that rise above the ordinary are hard to find. However, Poco Tapas & Wine breaks the mould, offering an intimate, seasonal experience that stands out from the crowd. Drawing inspiration from Spain’s tapas culture – where “poco“ means “a little“ – chef/owner Jeff Slessor opened Poco in February 2023. With over 30 years global culinary experience, Jeff aimed to create a venue that he and his partner and fellow owner, Catherine Rose, would enjoy themselves. Jeff describes the cuisine as “simple, fresh, and unfussy with big flavours.“ The menu is crafted for sharing and evolves with the seasons, featuring contemporary tapas and larger plates made from quality, locally sourced ingredients. Guests are encouraged to embrace communal dining, sampling a variety of dishes alongside a curated selection of wines, New Zealand craft beers, and signature cocktails.

Insider foodie tip: If you’re hungry, opt for the four-course chef’s menu for $75 – it’s an absolute steal and full of the best bits.

FIFE LANE

Fife Lane is dedicated to providing the ultimate steak experience and boy does it deliver. Proudly featured in the World’s 101 Best Steak Restaurants, it ranks 69th globally, making it the only New Zealand restaurant on the list and placing The Bay on the international dining map. Owner Kat Dippie explains, “The menu showcases a blend of locally sourced ingredients, premium meats, and fresh seafood, combined with flavours and techniques inspired by Mediterranean, Asian, and classic European culinary traditions.“ Robbie Webber designs the menus alongside head chef Dylan Burrows, focusing on seasonal produce and delivering simple yet balanced flavours. After five years of playing an A-game with steak, they have recently introduced a Butcher Book, a curated collection of the finest cuts from the Asia-Pacific region, available in limited quantities. “Once it’s gone, it’s gone,“ explains Kat, turning every dining experience into a unique adventure.

Insider foodie tip: Indulge in the Coconut Chilli Margarita, arguably the best cocktail in the Bay.

Beyond the traditional

Face the future